Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I believe you can specify the amount you're depositing into your account, though someone correct me if I'm wrong. My issue is with just not trusting PayPal. I do use them every now and then when I absolutely must, but I just don't store credit cards or bank accounts with them any longer.


Sorry if I'm not clear. I mean you can make a purchase using Paypal and a credit card without having an account. This is separate than having a Paypal account, funding it and then purchasing via transfer("purchase") to another Paypal account.


Usually true, but not always -- for people in "high risk" countries Paypal sometimes refuses to accept a credit card unless you create a Paypal account first.


Got it. Thank you. But isn't this a separate issue and more to card issuance by Visa/Mastercard/Diner's etc? Won't Stripe likely have the same restrictions to cover themselves...or in time after they've been burned enough as well?


Stripe doesn't need to "cover themselves" as much as Paypal, since they have more information about their merchants and hold on to money for a week.


While true, there is an annoying edge case: If you have (at some point) linked your credit card to a PayPal, then PayPal forces you to log in to pay. You simply can't use the non-login path if the card has a PayPal account.

Some reasons why this is annoying, that I can think of: (1) It makes the process more complex. Some people just close their window when forced to log into something. (2) It makes writing tutorials/documentation harder. 'Just fill in your credit card details' becomes a long sentence listing the different things that can happen. (3) I have had some customers who complained that they had forgotten about their PayPal account and had to go through the "forgot password" sequence in order to pay. I imagine that the percentage of people who didn't complain but simply closed the tab is higher.


> If you have (at some point) linked your credit card to a PayPal, then PayPal forces you to log in to pay.

This is not true. I have a long unused PayPal account that hasn't been canceled, and on the occasion that I do end up buying something from someplace that only accepts PayPal, upon entering my information they ask if I would like to sign in and pay with a large "YES" button, or a very small "No, continue without signing in" link which acts the same as not having an account with them at all.

Edit: see Colin's child remark to the parent comment of yours. this may only happen in non-high-risk countries that allow payment without accounts.


Thanks. It is entirely possible that my information is out of date.

If you know of a site where I can trivially test this (ie., small amount, no signup or shipping required), I would be happy to test. I am not in a position to test my own stuff as it is currently all based on recurring payments (which requires a PayPal account).




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: