I don't remember what I got the first couple of times I answered honestly. I do remember manipulating the system to become a Paladin, which perhaps negates the entire point of the morality system and makes me a rogue in real life.
Yeah, I did the same thing. I wanted to be a Ranger, because Aragorn in Lord of the Rings is one, so I manipulated my answers. Plus it's in the center of the graph, so I thought that had to be better.
But, I do recall I would get Mage (Honesty) if I did it, er... honestly. Today I get Bard (Compassion). I guess people really do change over the course of their life.