Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I really do not understand this Bitcoin promotion in comparison with gold. I think that majority of people do not have gold, never had and never will. It would reach a much bigger audience if Bitcoin was compared to credit cards and Paypal.


Gold has a strong market as a store of value that doesn't depend on government. The characteristics that make it good for this: it is naturally scarce, doesn't degrade, it's easily divided, you can hold a lot of value in a small amount of physical weight (compare to silver), it's fairly easy to exchange for local currency at a time of your choosing. Hence, it has historically functioned as a store of value.

Bitcoin has been designed to have the same advantages. It's weaker because it's more complex to deal with (at the moment). But it's stronger than gold in that - so long as the algorithm holds - its scarcity is guaranteed, and it's easy to use for electronic transactions.

Bitcoins compete with gold for mindshare with people who want to be able to store value in a way that isn't subject to the whims of government - who can start printing lots of money at any time of their choosing and thereby wipe out people with savings.


If bitcoin is a means of exchange but not a store of value, you need some extra means of exchange to convert your stored value into bitcoins and for the recipient to convert their bitcoins back into stored value. And if you've got that extra means of exchange, what do you need bitcoin in the middle for?

I mean, why go My bank -> Debit card -> Bitcoin exchange -> My wallet -> Merchant's wallet -> Bitcoin exchange -> Bank transfer -> Merchant's bank when you could just go My bank -> Debit card -> Merchant's bank?


There is huge speculative value in gold as a "store of wealth" and there are reasons why gold was in hands of many and now in the hands of few. Looking from this perspective helps understand why Bitcoin might be valuable in the long run for many people.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: